How Game Developers Make Money: Ads vs. In-App Purchases

The gaming industry has evolved into one of the most lucrative sectors in the entertainment world, with millions of players across the globe engaging in different types of games. Whether it’s a casual mobile game, a complex RPG, or a social multiplayer experience, developers have various strategies for monetizing their creations. Two of the most common and widely adopted strategies are in-app purchases (IAPs) and advertisements (ads). Both offer distinct advantages, but they also come with their challenges. In this article, we’ll explore how these monetization methods work, their pros and cons, and which might be the best fit for different types of games.

1. In-App Purchases (IAPs): The Player Pays

In-app purchases are a form of monetization where players can buy virtual items or enhancements within the game. These items could range from cosmetic upgrades (such as skins or avatars), to convenience features (like power-ups or currency), or even content that unlocks new levels or features.

How IAPs Work

When a player downloads a free game, they have access to a limited version of the game. However, they are constantly offered the chance to spend money on in-game items that enhance their experience. This could be anything from buying a virtual currency (like gems or coins), to unlocking new levels, or purchasing boosters to make gameplay easier. IAPs are usually integrated into the game through pop-up windows, store buttons, or through limited-time events or sales.

Types of In-App Purchases

1. Consumables: These are items that can be used up and need to be purchased again (e.g., extra lives, in-game currency, or power-ups).
2. Non-Consumables: These are items that the player buys once and can use permanently (e.g., a special character or a game expansion).
3. Subscriptions: Many games have moved towards offering subscriptions for access to exclusive content, VIP features, or an ad-free experience. Players may also receive rewards periodically with a subscription model.

Advantages of IAPs

1. High Profit Potential: IAPs can generate a substantial income, especially in games that attract a large, engaged user base. The more players invest in the game, the more money developers can earn. Games like “Fortnite” and “Clash of Clans” have made billions of dollars from in-app purchases alone.
2. Better Player Retention: Offering enticing items can encourage players to stay engaged with the game. The sense of progression or exclusivity that comes with in-app purchases can motivate players to keep coming back.
3. Flexibility: IAPs offer flexibility in how they are structured. Developers can offer a range of purchase options at different price points, allowing them to cater to both casual players and those willing to spend more.

Disadvantages of IAPs

1. Pay-to-Win Concerns: In games where in-app purchases provide significant advantages (such as better gear, faster progression, or extra lives), players may feel the game is unfair, leading to negative reviews and a drop in active users.
2. Requires Constant Updates: To keep players engaged, developers need to continually create new content or limited-time events. If a game becomes stale, players may stop spending money, which can harm the developer’s income.
3. Churn Rate: Not all players are willing to spend money. As a result, the game’s monetization largely depends on the “whales” – a small percentage of players who spend large amounts of money. If this group stops spending, revenue can quickly dwindle.

2. Advertisements (Ads): Monetizing Through Viewership

In contrast to IAPs, advertisements (ads) are another way for game developers to generate revenue without requiring players to spend money directly. Ads are typically shown to players at intervals during gameplay, such as before or after a level, or in exchange for a reward, like extra lives or in-game currency.

How Ads Work in Games

Ads are typically served through an ad network, such as Google AdMob, Unity Ads, or Facebook Audience Network. These networks provide developers with a platform to display ads to players, earning revenue based on impressions or interactions with the ads. The two primary types of ads are:

1. Interstitial Ads: These full-screen ads appear at natural transition points during gameplay, like between levels or after completing certain actions. Players are typically required to close the ad before continuing.
2. Rewarded Ads: In this model, players are given the option to watch an ad in exchange for a reward, such as in-game currency, extra lives, or special boosts. Rewarded ads have proven to be more effective since they provide a clear value proposition for players.
3. Banner Ads: These ads appear as small, static banners typically at the top or bottom of the screen during gameplay. Banner ads don’t interrupt the player experience, but they also tend to have lower engagement and revenue.
4. Native Ads: These ads are designed to match the look and feel of the game’s interface, making them feel less intrusive. Native ads are often used in conjunction with other ad formats to maximize ad engagement.

Advantages of Ads

1. Non-Intrusive for Players: Ads provide a way for developers to monetize without requiring players to spend money. Players can enjoy the game for free while developers still generate revenue from ads.
2. Low Barrier to Entry: Since players don’t have to make any purchases, they’re more likely to engage with the game. This can lead to higher user acquisition rates.
3. Wide Audience Appeal: Ads work particularly well for games that have a broad, casual audience. Since most people are willing to watch a short ad for a reward, ad-based monetization can be very effective for casual or hyper-casual games.

Disadvantages of Ads

1. Player Annoyance: Ads, especially interstitial ones, can disrupt the gameplay experience, leading to frustration among players. If ads are shown too frequently or are too intrusive, they can result in higher uninstall rates and negative reviews.
2. Low Revenue Per User: Unlike IAPs, where high-spending players can generate significant revenue, ad revenue tends to be lower and more dependent on the number of impressions or views. For ad-based monetization to be effective, a game needs a large player base.
3. Ad Fatigue: Players may become desensitized to ads, especially if the same ads are shown repeatedly. This can decrease the overall effectiveness of ad monetization.

3. IAPs vs. Ads: Which One is Better?

Choosing between in-app purchases and advertisements depends on the type of game being developed, the target audience, and the developer’s goals.

Casual and Hyper-Casual Games

For games that are free-to-play and cater to a broad audience, such as puzzle or endless runner games, advertisements are typically the best option. Since these games often have short sessions and a wide player base, ads can generate steady revenue without requiring players to make any purchases. Additionally, offering rewarded ads can be an effective way to engage players and encourage them to watch ads in exchange for in-game rewards.

Mid-Core and Hardcore Games

For mid-core and hardcore games that focus on player progression, storylines, and deeper gameplay, in-app purchases may be a more viable option. These types of games attract players who are willing to pay for convenience, cosmetic upgrades, or extra content. With the right balance, developers can create an enjoyable experience while offering players the option to spend money to enhance their gaming experience.

Combining Both Monetization Models

Many successful games use a hybrid approach, combining in-app purchases with advertisements. This method allows developers to cater to both paying players and those who prefer a free experience. For example, a game could have a robust in-app purchase system, while also providing rewarded ads for players who want to earn in-game currency or boosts without spending money.

4. Conclusion

Both in-app purchases and advertisements offer unique opportunities for game developers to monetize their games. The best monetization strategy depends on the type of game, its audience, and the developer’s goals. In-app purchases provide higher potential revenue but can alienate players who don’t want to spend money. On the other hand, ads offer a non-intrusive way to earn revenue, but may not generate as much income per player.

Ultimately, the most successful developers will carefully consider both options and strike a balance that aligns with their audience’s preferences and the type of game they’re creating. Whether they lean towards IAPs, ads, or a combination of both, the key to success in game monetization is creating a compelling experience that keeps players engaged and invested.

Read more about How Casual Games Are Taking Over the Gaming Industry